Country Living editors select each product featured. If you buy from a link, we may thumbprint cookies a commission. The sweetest way to spread holiday cheer this year? Out of all the Christmas cookie recipes out there, thumbprints are definitely the ones that bring us the most nostalgia.
Talk about a showstopper of a recipe. Kids will enjoy decorating these confections with festive sprinkles and icing. Get the recipe at Number 2 Pencil. Créme de Menthe liqueur and baking chips. Get the recipe at The Cookie Rookie.